Skip to main content
Illustrative Scenarios

Illustrative Enforcement Scenarios

Hypothetical scenarios illustrating common state enforcement issues for investment advisers. These educational examples help you understand what regulators look for and how to avoid similar outcomes.

These scenarios are hypothetical, written for educational purposes. They are not real cases and do not describe any actual firm or enforcement action; the fines and outcomes shown are illustrative only.

Misleading Performance Advertising

Advertising Violations · Hypothetical

Hypothetical Scenario

A state-registered RIA with 45 clients published marketing materials on their website and social media showing backtested performance results without required disclosures. The materials implied guaranteed returns and cherry-picked favorable time periods.

Violation

Violation of the state advertising rule: misleading performance presentation, implying guaranteed returns, and presenting backtested (hypothetical) results without the disclosures or conditions the rule requires.

Illustrative Regulatory Response

The state issued a consent order requiring removal of all non-compliant materials, implementation of an advertising review process, payment of a $25,000 fine, and retention of an independent compliance consultant for 12 months.

Lessons Learned

  • •Under the SEC Marketing Rule and NASAA's 2026 model amendments, gross performance must be shown with net performance
  • •Backtested results are hypothetical performance and are subject to strict conditions
  • •Social media posts that promote advisory services can be advertisements subject to the same rules
  • •A documented pre-publication review process is essential

Inadvertent Custody Failure

Custody Failures · Hypothetical

Hypothetical Scenario

An RIA principal served as trustee for three client trusts, creating a custody situation the firm failed to recognize. The firm did not arrange for surprise examinations, did not disclose the custody on Form ADV, and did not ensure clients received custodian statements.

Violation

Multiple violations of the state custody rule: acting as trustee without recognizing custody obligations, failure to undergo surprise examination, incomplete Form ADV disclosures.

Illustrative Regulatory Response

The state required the advisor to resign as trustee, undergo two consecutive surprise examinations, amend Form ADV, implement custody identification procedures, and pay a $15,000 fine.

Lessons Learned

  • •Serving as trustee or holding authority to withdraw client funds creates custody
  • •Annual custody assessments should identify all potential custody situations
  • •Form ADV must accurately reflect all custody arrangements
  • •When custody exists, an annual surprise examination is required unless an exception (such as the fee-deduction safeguards) applies

Systematic Record-Keeping Failures

Record-Keeping Deficiencies · Hypothetical

Hypothetical Scenario

During a routine exam, regulators discovered that a 20-person RIA had no email archiving system, missing client files for 30% of accounts, no documentation of annual compliance reviews, and incomplete trade records.

Violation

Failure to create and maintain required books and records under the state books and records rule. Missing client correspondence, incomplete trade documentation, and no evidence of compliance program oversight.

Illustrative Regulatory Response

The firm was ordered to implement an electronic document management system, reconstruct missing client files, hire a dedicated compliance officer, conduct a comprehensive compliance audit, and pay a $35,000 fine.

Lessons Learned

  • •Electronic communication archiving must be implemented from day one
  • •Every client account must have a complete documentation file
  • •Annual compliance reviews must be documented thoroughly
  • •Adequate record-keeping is fundamental to every other compliance obligation

Fiduciary Breach Through Conflicts

Fiduciary Breaches · Hypothetical

Hypothetical Scenario

An advisor recommended proprietary products and higher-cost share classes to clients without disclosing the additional compensation received. The advisor also failed to disclose revenue-sharing arrangements with product sponsors.

Violation

Breach of fiduciary duty through undisclosed conflicts of interest, failure to provide best execution, and inadequate disclosure of compensation arrangements in Form ADV Part 2A.

Illustrative Regulatory Response

The state required full client restitution of excess fees ($180,000), revision of all disclosure documents, implementation of a conflicts of interest policy, disgorgement of undisclosed compensation, and payment of a $50,000 fine.

Lessons Learned

  • •All compensation arrangements must be fully disclosed in Form ADV
  • •Fiduciary duty requires acting in the client's best interest, including weighing cost and disclosing conflicts
  • •Revenue-sharing and proprietary product preferences must be disclosed
  • •Regular conflicts of interest reviews should be part of the compliance program

Unregistered Advisory Activities

Registration Violations · Hypothetical

Hypothetical Scenario

A state-registered financial planner began advising clients in three additional states without registering there, relying on an incorrect reading of the de minimis exemption. The advisor had six or more clients in each state.

Violation

Conducting investment advisory business in states without required registration after exceeding the de minimis client threshold.

Illustrative Regulatory Response

The advisor was required to stop advising clients in those states until registered, register in each state, pay fines totaling $12,000, and implement a multi-state registration compliance procedure.

Lessons Learned

  • •Under Section 222(d) of the Advisers Act, a state cannot require registration only if the adviser has no place of business there and fewer than six client residents in the preceding 12 months
  • •Multi-state operations require careful registration tracking
  • •Registration must be in place before soliciting or advising clients in a state
  • •A registration compliance calendar prevents costly oversights

Prevent enforcement issues proactively

Compliance Approved keeps your policies, regulatory calendar, and home-state requirements in one place, and reviews marketing against SEC and FINRA rules.